CourtNews
law and justice

New York Senator Proposes Discipline for Judges Who Knowingly or Recklessly Use Fabricated Legal Authority

A new New York Senate bill would let regulators discipline judges who knowingly or recklessly put fabricated legal citations in rulings. It has not passed.

Thomas Bennett

Thomas Bennett

•Updated November 18, 2026
New York Senator Proposes Discipline for Judges Who Knowingly or Recklessly Use Fabricated Legal Authority

New York judges who knowingly or recklessly put invented case law into their rulings could face discipline, and even an impeachment referral, under a bill introduced in the state Senate on Nov. 16. Sen. Michelle Hinchey, a Democrat, filed S10741, the Judicial Artificial Intelligence Accountability and Integrity Act, as courts across the country deal with rulings tainted by AI-generated errors.

The measure is only a proposal. It was referred to the Senate Rules Committee the day it was filed, and neither chamber has voted on it. Reuters reports that it would be the first in any state to address AI misuse by judges specifically.

Using AI is not the offense. Reuters notes that AI use alone would not amount to misconduct under the bill. The target is narrower: a judge who puts fabricated authority into an official ruling, and does so knowingly or recklessly. That wording leaves room for honest mistakes.

"

…judges must be held to the highest standards of integrity, candor, and factual accuracy.

— Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, in a 2025 letter to two federal judges

The bill defines fabricated legal authority broadly. It covers nonexistent statutes, regulations and court decisions, along with invented quotations, citations and docket numbers, and real precedents that are materially misrepresented. The rule would reach opinions, orders, judgments, memoranda and other official judicial writings.

A judge who knowingly or recklessly includes, relies on or adopts that kind of material would be treated as having committed misconduct in office and conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice, according to the bill’s legislative summary.

Lawmakers also built in room for human error. Good-faith readings of unsettled law, immaterial typos or citation slips, and inadvertent mistakes corrected promptly without serious consequences for a case would not count.

How Discipline Would Work Through the Judicial Conduct Commission

Enforcement would run through the State Commission on Judicial Conduct, the body that already investigates and disciplines New York judges. Under the bill, it could impose sanctions using its existing procedures. If it issues a public determination of misconduct, it could also pass the matter to the Assembly, which would decide whether to consider impeachment.

Not every case would be treated alike. The commission would weigh how many fabricated authorities appeared and how serious they were, whether they changed the outcome, what verification steps the judge followed, any prior training, whether the conduct repeated and whether the error was fixed. The commission did not immediately respond to Reuters’ request for comment.

The Rulings Behind the Debate

The proposal follows a run of embarrassing episodes. In Mississippi, U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate withdrew a 2025 order riddled with errors. He later told Grassley a law clerk had used the AI tool Perplexity as a drafting assistant and that the draft reached the docket because of a lapse in oversight. On Oct. 22, 2026, the Fifth Circuit vacated an injunction Wingate issued in Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch (No. 25-60496) and ordered the case reassigned. The amended order, the court found, still cited a nonexistent Fourth Circuit decision, a problem that surfaced at oral argument.

Oklahoma supplied a state-court example. Stephens County Associate District Judge Lawrence Wheeler acknowledged using ChatGPT while researching a 2025 paternity order that cited at least two cases that do not exist, according to reporting based on state records.

Three Judges, Three Admissions

Each case below involved a judge or court staff acknowledging AI-linked errors:

✓ Henry Wingate, U.S. District Court in Mississippi: a law clerk’s AI-assisted draft reached the docket, and the Fifth Circuit reassigned the case

✓ Julien Neals, U.S. District Court in New Jersey: acknowledged that staff used AI in preparing an order Grassley called error-ridden

✓ Lawrence Wheeler, Stephens County, Oklahoma: acknowledged ChatGPT-sourced citations to two nonexistent cases in a paternity order

A Bloomberg Law analysis by Washington University law professor Oliver Roberts, as summarized by The Nigeria Lawyer, counted at least eight U.S. cases of judges issuing rulings built on fabricated authorities. It concluded those judges have largely avoided discipline, and argued that legislatures may need to step in.

What Happens Next for S10741

For now, the bill sits in the Senate Rules Committee. If it clears both chambers and becomes law, it would take effect 180 days later and cover only conduct on or after that date, so it would not reach rulings already issued.

New York’s court system is not starting from zero. Its administrative AI policy, adopted last year, says judges bear ultimate responsibility for the content of their opinions and orders. S10741 would add legal consequences for judges themselves.

California has a first-of-its-kind law taking effect in January that sets rules for how lawyers and arbitrators use generative AI, Reuters reports. Few states have rules that speak directly to AI in legal work.

a lapse in human oversight— Judge Henry Wingate, describing how an AI-assisted draft reached the docket, in a 2025 letter to Sen. Grassley

Keep the status clear: S10741 is a proposal, not law, and no committee action or vote has been reported. It also does not ban judges from using AI. Watch for movement in the Senate Rules Committee, a response from the Commission on Judicial Conduct, and whether an Assembly version is filed.


Sources


Share

Thomas Bennett
Thomas Bennett

Law And justice Author

Thomas Bennett is a senior legal journalist covering criminal justice reform, federal law enforcement, legislation, and national legal policy.