Federal regulators and prosecutors say an Indiana investment firm promised an “AI-driven” currency-trading engine that never lost a month, then paid older investors with money from newer ones.
The Securities and Exchange Commission, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and federal prosecutors in Manhattan filed parallel actions between Nov. 17 and Nov. 20 against Backward Hat Capital and its co-founders, Phillip Williams, 51, and Devin Johnson, 29. The SEC alleges the firm raised about $560 million from more than 2,000 investors. A federal judge has frozen assets and named a temporary receiver. None of the allegations has been proven in court.
Prosecutors in the Southern District of New York unsealed a criminal complaint on Nov. 18 charging both men with securities fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit securities fraud. Both are presumed innocent.
Investors were told their money would be converted to crypto assets and used for high-frequency foreign-exchange arbitrage by a proprietary algorithm. According to the SEC complaint, the pitch promised returns of at least 6% every month, and marketing claimed no month had fallen short since at least August 2023. The SEC says the funds did little or no real currency trading.
Instead, the SEC says more than $470 million, over 83% of the money raised, went either to earlier investors or to the founders and their companies. That includes more than $250 million in Ponzi-like payments and more than $220 million in transfers to insiders. Prosecutors put redemptions above $200 million and say Williams received more than $130 million and Johnson more than $40 million. The SEC says the money funded exotic cars, expensive homes, private air travel and Johnson’s gambling.
The agencies count differently. The SEC cites $560 million, prosecutors cite more than $600 million, and the CFTC cites more than $550 million from at least 2,100 participants. These are separate allegations, not a confirmed investor-loss total.
The Audit That Wasn’t
The complaint’s sharpest claim concerns the paperwork shown to cautious investors. The SEC alleges Joseph Anderson, 47, of Westfield, Indiana, wrote two “audit reports” and a quality-of-earnings report credited to an independent firm. The documents said the returns had been verified against bank and brokerage records.
The SEC says those records say otherwise. The reports stated that one fund held $246 million on July 31, 2025, yet its bank account held just $1.00 that day, and total deposits into it were under $2.5 million. The SEC also alleges Anderson’s firm does not perform audits, was not independent, and that he received about $2.5 million of investor money.
A Scheme Still Expanding as It Strained
The SEC says the operation kept growing. Since 2025, it alleges, Johnson created new vehicles, AI Capital and later Traders Point Capital, that pitched institutions the same track record. Traders Point applied to register as an investment adviser on Sept. 11, 2026, and a related fund reported a $300 million offering. The CFTC says solicitation continued through at least October.
By autumn, the SEC says, withdrawal requests were going unpaid, and on Oct. 9 the main Backward Hat accounts held about $500,000.
Where the Money Allegedly Landed
The SEC names relief defendants to recover funds they allegedly have no legitimate claim to. They are not charged with fraud in that complaint.
✓ Backward Hat Capital Fund LP: $385 million allegedly received
✓ BHC V LLC: $180 million
✓ KMAP Inc., a Williams-owned company: $93 million in net payments
✓ Allen Johnson Group LLC, a Johnson-owned company: $41 million
✓ Droplight LLC, a sports-sponsorship company: $31 million
Droplight is not named in the criminal complaint. Butler Athletics, one of its sponsorship partners, said it is reviewing its agreement.
What Happens Next
Williams appeared in federal court in Indiana on Nov. 18, and Johnson was scheduled to appear in Arizona on Nov. 19.
A federal court in Indiana froze the defendants’ and relief defendants’ assets on Nov. 18. On Nov. 20 it appointed Kevin B. Duff as temporary receiver to take control of the company defendants, certain relief defendants and the individuals’ assets, the CFTC says. The agencies seek restitution, disgorgement, civil penalties and permanent bans. The criminal counts carry maximum prison terms of 20, 20 and five years, which Congress sets and which are not predicted sentences. Possible victims can use the FBI’s page at fbi.gov/backwardhatinvestors.
Watch for a ruling on longer-term asset freezes, the receiver’s first findings and any grand jury indictment in New York. Until then, every figure in this case is an allegation.
Sources
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: SEC Charges Indianapolis-Based Backward Hat Capital and Its Co-Founders With $560 Million Dollar Offering Fraud and Obtains Emergency Reliefsec.gov(opens in a new tab)
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: Complaint, SEC v. Backward Hat Capital Management LLC, et al.sec.gov(opens in a new tab)
- U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York: Two Individuals Charged In $600 Million Ponzi Schemejustice.gov(opens in a new tab)
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission: CFTC Charges 11 Companies and Two Indiana Executives in $550 Million Fraud Schemecftc.gov(opens in a new tab)
- CFTC: Complaint, CFTC v. Backward Hat Capital Fund LP, et al.cftc.gov(opens in a new tab)
- CFTC: Temporary Receiver Order, CFTC v. Backward Hat Capital Fund LP, et al.cftc.gov(opens in a new tab)
- Focal News: Federal Charges in $600M Forex Ponzi Scheme Ripple Through Indiana Sports Sponsorshipsfocalnews.org(opens in a new tab)
- ABC15 Arizona: Man arrested in Gilbert charged in alleged $600 million Ponzi schemeabc15.com(opens in a new tab)







